The Unflappable Captain Mwai

A study in panel borders:
Inspired by this awesome post about making comics quickly, I took a look at some comics I own to get some sense of different kinds of panel design choices.

I came away feeling like I’d learned a little less than I’d hoped, but here are some takeaways:

* You can get away with smaller panels than you think
* Extremely weird comic panels CAN work, but when it fails it looks painful and forced.
* Simple is not bad.
* There are actually a LOT of possible combinations.

Specific notes:

Scott McCloud uses a 4x3 sliceup of the page, and it’s four VERTICAL slices and three HORIZONTAL ones, which is weird because it makes the panels, on average, LESS square. This works with the particular comic really WELL though, because he draws himself in closeup, talking, a LOT.

DAR and Narbonic both are webcomics mashed into book format, but both worked surprisingly well as page layout in the end.

Blacksad is REALLY variable and the page layouts are hand-crafted on a per-page basis. No speed gains here, but perhaps a message that full custom has its place.

The Resonator is fairly formal but never *too* rigid with panel choices. Lots of narrow or tall panels, which works as a way to alternate between big establishing shots and dense dialog. Very tall panels for single speaker, long ones for two-person dialog or to combine a lot of text and visuals. In general, Resonator is print-native and has TINY text…

Ultimate X-Men is a fun read but the panel design is a disaster. Almost none of the choices of graphic design work at all. Occasionally an establishing shot hits home, but in general the layout is trying WAY too hard.

Watchmen. Formalism raised to the ultimate. It’s precise, it’s a 3x3 grid, it’s piss-on-a-plate-with-no-spills precise and that’s fine, for two reasons: one, everything is about time, and two, it gets the panels the hell out of the way of the story.

Augustus is an example of what Ultimate X-Men was trying to do, except it succeeds. Lots of variation, but on average very orderly. Kind of strikes me as the sort of thing you “have to be GOOD” to pull off well.

Update: I’ve also added:
Part 2
and All 72 Possible 2x3 Panel Grids

  1. ragdollpotato reblogged this from helpfulharrie
  2. mihariri reblogged this from captainmwai
  3. flickflack313 reblogged this from starfruitandref
  4. starfruitandref reblogged this from art-and-sterf
  5. thehiddenpatchh reblogged this from cookiekhaleesi
  6. aye--candy reblogged this from candiedcanid
  7. stylesandreferences reblogged this from itsvondell
  8. hushbutt reblogged this from blindsprings
  9. anonymomo reblogged this from qunerdi
  10. qunerdi reblogged this from lascocks
  11. groggygumbo reblogged this from chipperwhale
  12. azombiesinspiration reblogged this from rexobxo
  13. phoebusserenatur reblogged this from helpyoudraw
  14. gootie reblogged this from madhumandesigns
  15. madhumandesigns reblogged this from helpyoudraw
  16. kikiinspire reblogged this from rexobxo
  17. striped-ref reblogged this from cookiekhaleesi
  18. greatcaesarsstabwound reblogged this from dizzykins7
  19. sventastical reblogged this from only-ronnie
  20. rampagetime reblogged this from siminib
  21. referenceworks reblogged this from referencetortall
  22. darkangelkarasu reblogged this from umadashibayashi
  23. siminib reblogged this from clairelikesthings
  24. phantomlighters reblogged this from angrycinnabun
  25. clairelikesthings reblogged this from rexobxo
  26. umadashibayashi reblogged this from dreamyprincessparty and added:
    I took these panel layouts from a chapter of Black Jack by Osamu Tezuka. You can see that as the action heats up in the...
  27. stoneclaw reblogged this from rexobxo